Here is My Dream,

Here is What Happened

By Derrek Stewart 9/19/18, updated 11/20/25

What an incredible fish! A 24-pound Arctic Char from Plummer’s Lodge, I dream of catching fish like this. 

I must be in the wrong place; this Brook Trout is also a Char, but nothing like the ones at Plummer’s.

Char species are often misidentified as trout. Many Char species have "trout" in their common names, further adding to the confusion. The Arctic char / Salvelinus alpinus is a cold-water fish, native to alpine lakes, Arctic, and subarctic coastal waters.

The mount in the title image is at the main lodge of Plummer's Lodges on Great Bear Lake, Northwest Territories, Canada. Plummer's represents an angling adventure of a lifetime. https://Plummerslodges.com

In the second image, I'm holding a Brook trout / Salvelinus fontinalis, a freshwater species also in the Char genus. This 'Brookie', a nickname, was caught and released in a stream located in the Ansel Adams Wilderness region of California's Sierra Nevada mountains. The Sierra Nevada Mountains are stunningly beautiful and another worthy angling adventure.

Notice that the two species share similar markings. This Brook Trout Illustration is for marking comparison to the Arctic Char mount above. The illustration is by Duane Raver and is from the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, public domain.

Size is relative, and fish often grow to a particular size based on the size of their environment and the number of fish that occupy it. I'm enjoying some self-deprecation based on the size juxtaposition of the two separate fish from the same genius. Which one would you prefer to catch?