Beauty and the Beast, Sometimes They're the Same

A Catch of a Lifetime on a Trip of a Lifetime

By Derrek Stewart 12/19/25

Prelude

Transcribed from my copious notes directly after an astonishing catch in August of 2014, this is a factual account. The event at Great Bear Lake in the Northwest Territories, Canada, was a special moment during a self-guided adventure at the Arctic Circle Outpost, part of the outstanding fishing trips provided by Plummer's Lodges. I'm excited to share this with you, and the first detailed publication.

Beauty and the Beast

The story begins the day before the incredible catch, when I spotted a great fish. Angling for trophy Lake Trout, it was during a long cast with an Eppinger Husky Devle spoon, on the retrieve, just as the lure came into view in the clear, pristine waters of Great Bear Lake, I observed a massive fish.

Great Bear Lake Location Map

She was reacting to my lure, tracking just below the spoon. As soon as I saw this incredible fish, she paused, suspended like a haunting, distant, blue-gray-toned, shadowy figure. I was awestruck by her mass. I commented to my fishing partner, Bill Siemantal, " A big fish just followed my retrieve." The two of us had previously experienced excellent fishing at this unique location; we were relatively close to the lodge, so there was a strong possibility we would revisit this spot.  

A massive Lake Trout, barely visible, forever imprinted in my mind. A fish of this magnitude was what we were after.

The location is a long-submerged reef. There is a channel running between the shore and the reef. The fish use the entire length of this 200-yard ridge line, the adjacent channel, and the drop-offs on the opposite side. It starts deeper as you approach from the lodge. It's slightly wider at the far end; long, straight, and linear, it begins to ascend as you move away from the lodge. At the far end, a boulder-laden flat forms, reaching up within a few shallow feet from the surface.

When the wind creates choppy surface water, the high spot is visible from afar; that's how I found this prime location. Continue past the high spot, and the ridgeline ends, breaking dramatically fast into deep water as the main channel makes a turn directly across this end of the ridge. Here, several distinct structural and cover elements converge, enhanced by the wind and subsequent current that sweeps down its long axis. By every definition, it's prime water for what the fish are doing that time of year.

Lake Trout swim in amazing places. The pristine beauty of the Arctic Circle Outpost area of Great Bear Lake is awe-inspiring. 

Sure enough, the following day, a return visit was in order.  As we worked our way towards the high boulder end, I played back in my mind the image of the giant, shadowy fish. The large Husky Delve spoons we were casting, with the right gear, accounted for long, smooth casts. When you become proficient at casting these big spoons and your body mechanics hit all 'cylinders,' just like a well-thrown Frisbee, it will catch the air, fly straight like an arrow without tumbling. Splashdown, flutter down, pop the rod tip, and feel the pulse. The thump on your line tells you that your lure isn't fouled, and your Huskie Devle is running true.

5.5" Husky Devle spoons, two trolling rigs, and one casting rig above. All three spoons feature lure modifications. The pink on top, with shiny silver on the bottom, is the actual spoon the beast ate. The chips in the paint are Lake Trout teeth marks.

Like a true swimbait-big-bait angler, I stared down the line of my retrieve, waiting for my spoon to come into view. I'm scanning past the lure, looking for a tracking fish, and that's when I spot, presumably, the same fish. However, this time, this massive fish kept coming; the beast tracked my offer all the way to the boat.  I ran out of water but not out of options.

The fish was 'Locked On,' like a jet fighter pilot; she had 'Tone.' If you fish swimbaits, primarily big baits high in the water column, you're going to see your fair share of followers. Observe enough followers, and you'll have the opportunity to learn the body language of predatory fish. It’s possible to read a predator's demeanor, and when the hunter is ready to pounce.

My retrieve was boat-side; a giant fish was within inches of my lure, and I had to make an immediate decision. Without thought or hesitation, I commenced a Figure Eight maneuver, at which point this incredible Lake Trout tackled my deception, breaching the surface, and CRASHING onto the side of the boat.  Six feet of braid separated us as I set the hook.

The Great Bear Laker, now aware of the situation, immediately dove hard for the depths. With the drag locked, the Laker pulled me down. I knew what was at stake, and again, without thought, I held my arms and my gear high, making sure my line was free from impediments, sacrificing my body as I slammed into the hard metal floor of the boat.

Back on my feet, adjusting the drag on my reel, and the battle was on!

At 52 lbs., this Beast is Beautiful!